In April I took a call from the outside bookkeeper of a business we work with. Their team needed to get into the business's finance inbox to pick up supplier bills and the client emails that go with them. The trouble was two-factor authentication. Every time someone from the bookkeeping team signed in, the code went to the owner's phone. We needed a way to give the bookkeeper access to the email without anyone passing codes around.

So each login meant a message to the owner asking for a code, which is slow for everyone. It's a really common setup, and nobody had done anything wrong. The inbox had been set up by a previous IT person for one person to use, and then more people needed it.

Two-factor is doing its job

Two-factor authentication, or MFA, means a password alone isn't enough to sign in. You also need a code or approval from something you have, usually your phone. The ACSC recommends turning it on wherever you can, and I agree. The fix here is to keep it on and change who can receive the code.

Ways to give a bookkeeper access to your email

Shared or delegated mailboxes. In Microsoft 365 this is the cleanest answer. A shared mailbox has no password of its own. You give people access, and they open it with their own login and their own two-factor. This inbox was a Gmail account, though, and Gmail has no shared mailbox you can just hand someone access to. Gmail does let you add a delegate, but the delegate needs their own Google account, and the bookkeeper was an outside business that runs on Microsoft.

Forwarding. We could forward every email from the finance inbox to the bookkeeper. That's easy, but it puts a copy of every finance email in someone else's inbox, which has security implications. The bookkeeper also didn't want their inbox filling up with things she'd have to sort through.

A second sign-in method. What I recommended was keeping the owner's authenticator app as the main method and adding a backup that the bookkeeping team controls, like their phone number or email address. When they sign in, the authenticator is offered first. They pick another way to sign in, choose their own number or email, and the code comes straight to them. Nobody has to text anyone.

I couldn't set it up on that call. I didn't have admin access to the account yet, and who gets into a finance inbox is the owner's call, not mine or the bookkeeper's. When we picked it up again in July, I added the bookkeeper's phone number as a second two-factor method on the account, alongside the owner's. Now the bookkeeper gets their own code when they sign in, and nobody has to text anyone. It's honestly not the tidiest way to do it, but for a Gmail inbox it was the most practical option.

What to take from this

If you're the only person who can approve sign-ins to an inbox other people need, it's worth fixing before it turns into friction. On Microsoft 365, I'd use a shared mailbox and let everyone sign in as themselves. On Google, adding a backup method for the person who needs access is usually the simplest path. Either way, keep two-factor on. If you're weighing up whether Microsoft 365 suits a business with outside helpers, our Microsoft 365 plan guide covers the plans.

A good first step is to list every inbox your bookkeeper, VA or office manager needs, and whose phone the codes go to for each one.