For most small local businesses, Facebook ads are the cheaper place to start, and Google Ads can wait. On Google you're bidding against every other business chasing the same search, so a small budget buys very few clicks. Facebook and Instagram reach people before they start searching, for a lot less. Google Ads starts to make sense once you've got the staff to handle steady volume and you need new customers every day. Before either, make sure your Google profile and reviews are doing their job, because that's free.

Why Facebook usually beats Google Ads on a small budget

A massage therapist I spoke with had already tested this herself. She put a small amount into Facebook and Instagram ads, and some into Google. Facebook and Instagram got her more response. Google cost a lot more for less.

That's a pretty common result, and it comes down to where each one sits.

Google Ads catches people who are already looking. Someone types the service and their suburb into Google, and the ads at the top are businesses that bid on those words. Every business doing the same work in your area can bid on the same search. Google runs an auction every time an ad is eligible to show, and where you land depends on your bid, how good and relevant your ad is, and who else is in the auction at that moment. When lots of businesses are competing for a handful of searches, a small budget doesn't go far.

Facebook and Instagram reach people earlier. They aren't searching for you yet. You're putting your work in front of local people while they scroll, so you're not fighting everyone else for the same few searches. Meta's own overview of ways to promote your business on Facebook covers the options, from boosting a post to full ad campaigns.

When Google Ads starts to pay

What I told her was that I wouldn't run paid ads at all yet. She was already showing around fourth in the local results for her main search, and her clients come back again and again.

Google Ads becomes worth a look when a few things line up:

  • You've got capacity. Three or four staff, say, and you need to fill the diary every day.
  • Customers don't come back much. If most jobs are one-offs, you need a constant stream of new people, and catching them at the moment they search is worth paying for.
  • You know what a customer is worth. If you know roughly how much a typical customer spends with you over the years, you can work out what you can afford to pay to win one.

For a solo operator with lots of repeat clients, keeping the clients you've got is worth more than paying to find new ones.

What to do before you spend on either

These cost nothing but time, and they usually move the needle more than a small ad budget.

  1. Get reviews, every time. Every client who hasn't left a Google review gets a short email asking if they enjoyed the session and whether they'd leave one. Our guide to getting more Google reviews covers how to ask.
  2. Look after your Google profile. It's how most local people will find you on Maps. See our Google Business Profile page.
  3. Stay in touch with existing clients. A simple email with a few useful tips between visits keeps you front of mind without asking them to rebook. She could design it in Canva and send it from an email tool.
  4. Post on social media when you can. Even a handful of real posts gives a future ad something to point at.

How to check what's actually working

  • Ask every new customer how they found you. Write it down. After a couple of months you'll know which channel earns its keep.
  • Count enquiries, not views. An ad with lots of views and no messages isn't working.
  • Test small and compare. Run the same small amount on each for the same period and count real enquiries from each one.
  • Stop what doesn't produce. If a channel isn't bringing in enquiries after a fair test, turn it off. She did exactly that with Google, which was the right call.

What I'd do this week

Look at where your last ten customers came from. If most came from referrals, reviews and your Google profile, put your effort there first and leave Google Ads for later.