We've got 130 Google reviews, all five stars, built up over years as Tech on Demand. Until last week, we didn't show up at all when someone searched for web design in Geelong, Torquay or Bannockburn.

The other web designers in those map results had somewhere between 3 and 69 reviews. We had two to four times as many and still weren't there. So the reviews weren't the problem.

Google thought we fixed computers

Our profile's primary category was still "Computer support and services", left over from the Tech on Demand days. The primary category is the one main label you pick for your business, and it's the strongest hint Google has about what you do. As far as Google was concerned, we were an IT support business. Someone searching for a web designer wasn't going to see us, however many reviews we had.

That's pretty normal after a rebrand or a change of direction. The name gets updated and the category gets forgotten.

What we changed

On 20 November we made these changes, in this order:

  1. Primary category changed to Website designer. For extra categories we added Marketing agency, Computer consultant and Internet marketing service, which cover the rest of what we actually do.
  2. Services rewritten in plain words, with typos fixed and anything we don't sell removed.
  3. Description rewritten to lead with what we do, where, and what customers get out of it.
  4. Social links fixed. One still pointed at an old Tech on Demand account.

The category is the one that mattered. The rest was tidying up so everything on the profile told Google the same story.

Two days later

On 22 November, a phone search for "web design bannockburn" from Bannockburn showed Avera Co first in the map pack. Two days earlier we weren't in it at all.

When I checked from my own phone in an incognito window, we were second in the map pack and first in Google's AI Overview, the summary that now sits above the results. The two don't always agree. The map pack leans heavily on how close you are to the person searching. The AI summary seems to lean more on your category, reviews and description.

We're not in the map pack for people searching from central Geelong yet. That's expected: it's further away, and the web designers there have reviews that mention web design. Ours mostly mention fixing computers, because that's what we did for years. That will change as new reviews come in.

What it taught me

Check your category before you chase reviews. If your category doesn't match the searches you want, more reviews won't fix it. Our guide to setting up a Google Business Profile covers picking one.

Pick from the categories Google actually offers. You can't type your own. Search the list for the plainest name for your main job, and use extra categories for the other things you do.

Incognito doesn't hide where you are. If you check your own ranking from your office, you'll see the results for your office. Your customers are searching from somewhere else.

Be honest about search volume. The keyword tools I use put "web design bannockburn" at about 10 searches a month, against about 260 for "web design geelong". Being first for a small town is a good start, not the finish line.

Rename before you delete. When we removed a duplicate service, Google was about to delete the original from every category too, because they shared a name. Renaming the duplicate first and then deleting it kept the real one.

Expect a re-verification. Changing categories can ask you to verify the business again. We'd just been through one, and a few older photos went back to pending for a while.

If your profile isn't showing up

Open your Google Business Profile and look at the primary category. If it doesn't describe the job you most want more of, that's the first thing I'd change. It takes a minute. Once that's right, reviews start pulling their weight, and our guide on getting more Google reviews covers the next step. If you'd rather we went through your profile with you, that's part of our Google Business Profile work.

I'll update this post with how it looks in a few weeks.