Back in February I visited a consultant who runs his business from a home office. He'd read one of our newsletters about Microsoft 365 subscriptions and wanted to talk about whether he still needed his. Underneath that was a bigger question, whether OneDrive counts as a backup.

Partway through, he told me why he kept it. He didn't much like OneDrive, but he used it for his backups, because it was the best system he'd managed to find. He did have another backup method too. It only worked when he remembered to run it, so it wasn't very reliable.

Most small offices I see do the same.

Is OneDrive a backup? What it's designed for

OneDrive is built for syncing and sharing files. Your files sit in the cloud and a copy sits on each of your devices, and when you change a file in one place, the change shows up everywhere else. That's really handy, and he did get some use out of the sharing side.

The catch is that syncing copies your mistakes as well. Delete a folder on your laptop, and it's deleted in OneDrive too. If ransomware scrambles your files, the scrambled versions sync up. OneDrive does keep deleted files in its recycle bin for a while, and it keeps older versions of files, which helps a lot. But it's still one system holding one live set of files, and if that account is closed or you lose access to it, your files go with it.

Microsoft's own Services Agreement, which covers personal Microsoft accounts, recommends you regularly back up the content you store on its services. That tells you how they see it.

His Microsoft 365 turned out to be a business account. It ran his work email and his files, and was set up through the company that also looks after his website. So cancelling it to save money would have taken his email with it. My advice was to keep it, and for us to review how it's set up.

On backups, I explained that OneDrive is a sharing tool. If he dropped it, he'd need two things to replace it: a new way to back up, and a new way to share files. So the plan was to keep OneDrive for what it does well, then look at a proper backup alongside it.

What a backup needs to do

For a business of one to five people, a backup doesn't need to be complicated. I'd want it to do three things:

  • Run on its own, without anyone remembering to start it.
  • Keep a separate copy that a delete or ransomware on your computer can't reach.
  • Tell you when it stops working.

The last one matters more than people think. I've seen external backup drives that just quietly stop. The drive spins up but won't open, and the last backup turns out to be more than a year old. Nothing warned anyone. Backups that don't say anything when they fail feel fine right up until you need them.

Regular backups are one of the Essential Eight from the Australian Cyber Security Centre, and they include testing that you can actually restore from them.

What to take from this

If OneDrive is your only backup, I'd do one thing this week. Try restoring a single file from wherever you think your backup is, and check the date on the latest copy. If you're not sure which Microsoft 365 plan you're on, our guide to Microsoft 365 plans explains the difference between personal and business accounts.