A quick note before I start: I've swapped the type of business in this story so it can't be traced back to the owner. Think of the mobile cocktail bar below as a stand-in. The conversation, the problem and what we worked out are all real. Underneath it was a question I hear a lot. Why would you rank first on Google and still get no leads?
At the start of November I sat down with the owner of a niche business that does weddings and events. For this post, let's call it a mobile cocktail bar. They only do cocktails, not a full bar with beer and wine on tap, and as far as they know nobody else nearby does quite the same thing. They wanted to talk about redesigning their website.
First I searched for them from a fresh guest window in my browser, so my history wouldn't skew it. They came up first for the searches that describe exactly what they do.
So their SEO was working. Their website still wasn't bringing in leads.
Why ranking first brought no leads
Search engine optimisation, or SEO, decides where you show up for a search. It can't make more people search.
Their terms are very specific, which is why they rank for them and also why so few people type them. If only a handful of people make that search each month, being first still only gets you a handful of visitors. When we looked at their traffic, the site had a small number of visits a month, and very few enquiries came from it.
You can check roughly how many people search a term each month with Google's Keyword Planner. Rankings also shift with Google's updates and where the person searching is, so check with a couple of tools rather than one search.
Where their work actually comes from
More than half their work comes from referrals, and most of the rest from wedding expos and venue supplier lists.
And one thing closes the deal better than anything else: a free tasting. Once a couple has a drink from the menu in their hand, the work mostly sells itself.
So what's the website for?
That changed the brief. The website's job is to get the right people to book a tasting. Here's what I'd change:
- Put a "Book a free tasting" button on every screen. On a phone, keep it near the bottom where your thumb sits.
- Lead with photos. Their home page had only a couple of photos of the drinks. Put the best ones at the top and collapse the menu down.
- Make the hero say something real. The owner said themselves that the message didn't feel clear. The headings were fine, but the text under them was polished and generic, and could have belonged to any events business. Say who it's for, what makes it different, and what to do next, in your own words.
- Screen the tasting requests. Free offers attract people who just want a free drink. A short form asks for the event date and guest numbers, and the owner sends times to people who are really planning an event.
The rest comes from people
Ask venues directly. Some venues they'd assumed would say no were happy to have them. Others really don't allow outside suppliers. Ask, and visit in the quiet season.
Give before you ask. Help a venue or an event planner a few times first. Then mention you're there if they ever want something extra for a guest list.
Partner with the business next to yours. They get enquiries for a full bar that they can't take. A line like "cocktails only, not a full bar" makes that clear. Point those enquiries to a local bar hire company, and the bar hire company can send couples back for a cocktail menu to go with it.
Ask better questions. Ask every enquiry how they found you. After a job, ask "Who do you know who'd like this?" rather than "Do you know anyone?"
What I'd take from this
If you rank well but your phone doesn't ring, check how many people actually search your terms before you pay for more SEO. Then build the site around the one step that turns a visitor into a customer. Our guide to what to put on your business website covers the basics, and Get Found explains how we help.
An easy first step is writing down where your last ten jobs came from.