In April I was at a client's place sorting out email and shared files when the conversation turned to sales. They run a small online shop, and they'd recently replaced their old website with a new Shopify site built from scratch. Since the redesign, their Google traffic had dropped right off.

Since then their Google traffic had collapsed. They'd only just set up Google Search Console, the free tool that shows how your site is doing in Google, and the graph had fallen off a cliff. Sales were down too.

That's a rough thing to find, and it's pretty common after a rebuild.

Why traffic drops after a website redesign

Over the years, Google had learned the old site's page addresses and was sending searchers to them.

When the new site went up, those old addresses stopped working. Nothing pointed from the old pages to the new ones, so as far as Google could tell, the pages people had been finding were gone. The new site had to start from close to zero.

Moving a site without losing that is called a site migration. The core of it is a redirect for every old page address, which automatically sends visitors and Google to the matching new page. Google's guide to moving a site with URL changes covers the steps, and its page on redirects explains which kind to use.

A rebuild from scratch skips that step unless someone plans for it, and here the redirects just weren't on the list.

How long it takes to come back

My estimate was three to six months for search traffic to really pick up again. Google has to find the new pages, work out what each one is about, and build trust in them all over again.

That's a long time to wait for sales, so I didn't suggest waiting.

What we did in the meantime

The fastest money was in the customers they already had. Before the old site was shut down, its customer list had been exported and imported into Shopify. That list was the best asset they had left, so the plan was email and SMS campaigns through Klaviyo, aimed at people who had already bought from them.

A few things I suggested along the way:

  1. Test the list first. An old export will have out-of-date addresses in it, so send to a small batch before the whole lot.
  2. Start with the products that already sell best. Their sales history only went back a few months, but it was enough to pick a few.
  3. Test one thing at a time: the subject line, the email itself, the page it links to, and the whole flow from inbox to checkout.
  4. Expect the first campaigns to underperform. You're learning what your customers respond to, and that takes a few sends.

Leave the small stuff for later

On a phone, a big announcement bar and a long drop-down menu pushed the products down the screen. Worth fixing eventually, but tweaks like that pay off once you have lots of visitors. Right then, existing customers came first.

What I'd tell anyone planning a rebuild

Before the old site comes down, get a list of every page address it has, and make sure each one redirects to the right new page on launch day. Our guide to fixing or rebuilding your website covers this, and it's part of any rebuild we do through our web design work.

If your rebuild has already happened, log in to Google Search Console and look at your traffic over the last six months. That'll tell you where you stand.