Twice this year I've untangled invoices that reached customers from two different places. Both times the job side was fine. The trouble was ServiceM8 and Xero both talking to the same customer.
Duplicate invoices in Xero
The first was a cleaning business. Every invoice went out from ServiceM8 when the job was done, which is how it should work. If the customer didn't pay, the owner went into Xero and sent the reminder from there.
The catch was a payment add-on that only worked on Xero invoices, so customers paying from a Xero reminder paid through it. Those payments didn't come through on their own, so the owner recorded each one by hand, and recording it created a brand new invoice in Xero. One job, two invoices. Their bookkeeper's team spent a long time cleaning up the Xero file afterwards.
A customer who paid twice
The second one was in July. This business invoices from ServiceM8 and uses ServiceM8 Pay, and some regular clients pay automatically by card each week.
Before the end of the financial year, a bulk batch of overdue reminders went out from Xero. One went to a client whose card payment was due that same day. They saw the reminder in the afternoon and paid by bank transfer straight away. That month the card charge ran a day late, and it came out the next evening and marked the invoice paid. So the client paid twice.
Here's why. The scheduled card charge lives in ServiceM8 Pay. Xero only finds out about a payment once it has actually gone through, so anyone looking at that invoice in Xero sees it as unpaid. ServiceM8 Pay will also retry a failed payment for up to three days, so an invoice can look overdue in Xero while a payment is still on its way.
One place sends, the other reflects
For the cleaning business, we moved everything into ServiceM8. Every invoice goes from ServiceM8, with automatic reminders: unpaid after a few days, a reminder goes out, and if it's still unpaid a couple of days later, another one. Nobody has to press a button. Xero doesn't send anything to customers any more, and the add-on is no longer part of it. Xero just reflects what's in ServiceM8, and the bookkeeper's team matched the recent invoices between the two and confirmed they line up.
For the double payment, my suggestion was to tell the client straight away, offer to refund the transfer, and only send reminders from ServiceM8 from then on. Applying the extra as a credit on the next invoice also works. I'd still let the client know either way. And before any bulk send from Xero, check with your bookkeeper first.
ServiceM8's invoicing features handle reminders and card payments from the job itself.
What to take from this
Pick one system to send invoices and reminders, and let the other one show the result. If you invoice from ServiceM8, chase from ServiceM8 too. On that same call, the bookkeeper mentioned another trade business in pretty much the same spot: the owner was invoicing from Xero while the jobs ran in ServiceM8. Two systems, where one would do.
If you're still choosing job software, our ServiceM8 vs Tradify guide covers how each one handles invoicing with Xero.
For an easy first step, open your last few reminder emails and check which system sent them. If it isn't the one that sent the invoice, that's the gap to close. Our get paid page covers the rest of the invoicing side.