In March a small business owner rang me because enquiries from his website's contact form kept turning up in his spam folder. Some days they came through fine. Other days he only found them when he went looking.
His site was built on Squarespace, using its built-in form. I filled the form in myself to test it, and it's a pattern I see heaps with website builders.
Why form emails get filtered
When someone fills in a Squarespace form, Squarespace sends you the enquiry by email from its own address, formsubmission@squarespace.info. You're not sending that email, and your own email settings don't touch it.
Spam filters keep a score for every sender. Squarespace itself has a good reputation, but that one form address sends enquiries for a huge number of websites. Some of those sites get junk submissions, so filters trust that address a bit less than they trust Squarespace generally. Every now and then a real enquiry gets caught.
GoDaddy's builder and the other build-it-yourself website tools have the same issue, because they all send form emails from one shared address.
If you've built your own forms with a service like Formspree and your own sending setup, it's different. Then your domain's SPF, DKIM and DMARC records need to be right, because the email is coming from you.
The three things I'd do
1. Add the form address to your safe senders. Put formsubmission@squarespace.info, or whatever address your builder uses, on the allow list in your email. Open one of the form emails to check the exact address.
2. Make a rule so form emails skip spam. In Gmail you can create a filter for that sender and tick "Never send it to Spam". Outlook has a similar safe senders setting. Between the first two, most of the problem goes away.
3. Send enquiries somewhere else as well. Have every form submission land in a second place, like a spreadsheet, your CRM or your job software, as well as your inbox. Then even if an email gets filtered, the enquiry is still sitting there. For a trade or service business, this is where I'd have form enquiries land straight in ServiceM8 as a new job.
Emails from someone you deal with
The same call turned up a supplier whose emails also kept going to spam. You can't change how someone else sends their email, but you can teach your own inbox. Add their address or their whole domain to your safe senders. When one lands in spam anyway, move it back to your inbox. Each time you do that, you're telling your filter it got it wrong.
What to take from this
If your website has a contact form, send yourself a test enquiry this week and see where it lands. If it's spam, the first two fixes are quick. If enquiries are how you get work, the third one is worth setting up so you never depend on one email getting through. Our guide on what to put on your business website covers how to make the contact page itself work harder.