Two people asked me to look at their websites in August. Both were half expecting me to say they needed a new one. I told them both to leave it alone for now.

A site she built herself

The first was a remedial massage therapist, a few months into working for herself. She'd built her own site with an AI coding tool. Under the hood the components were messy, but they worked, and the site did what she needed.

I could have rebuilt it properly and it would've been neater to maintain. But I couldn't see a rebuild bringing her a single extra client yet, and at her size that's the only job the website really has.

A slow site that didn't need to be fast

The second was a WordPress site for a business that gets almost all its work by word of mouth. It took about 9 seconds to load on mobile and 4 to 6 seconds on desktop. No caching, no lazy loading, and big images.

I aim for under 3 seconds, so on paper it was slow. Then I looked at who was visiting. Most people landed there already sold, because someone had recommended the business to them.

For how that site gets used, it was fine.

When I'd rebuild

For both of them, I'd rebuild when one of these happens:

  • you're fully booked, or hiring, and the site needs to bring in work for more people
  • the site has to win over strangers who've never heard of you

Until then, I reckon your money and time are better spent somewhere else. Our guide to website costs in Geelong covers what a rebuild involves when you get there. If the site just needs keeping updated and backed up in the meantime, that's what website care is for.

What mattered more

For both businesses, the Google Business Profile and its reviews mattered more than the website. That's where I suggested they put their time, and our guide to getting more Google reviews is a good place to start.

For the therapist, the bigger opportunity was the clients she already had. A lot of them come back, so keeping them coming back is worth more than chasing new ones. What I'd do is send existing clients a simple email every now and then with a useful tip. It keeps her in mind and doesn't ask them for anything.

A note on paid ads

She'd also tried a bit of paid advertising. A small test on social media did better for her than Google search ads, where the searches she wanted were pretty crowded. My advice was to leave search ads until she's got staff whose diaries need filling.

If your site is slow or a bit messy and you're not sure it matters, start by looking at who's visiting and why. If they're arriving already sold, there's probably something better to spend on first. When you do need a new site, that's where our web design comes in.