If you run a local business, you've probably had a directory rep ring about a featured listing, or wondered whether that old Yellow Pages entry still does anything. There are dozens of local business directories in Australia, and you can't be on all of them. So I counted which ones actually show up when people around Geelong search for a local business.
Which local business directories in Australia show up in Geelong searches
On 30 October 2026 we searched Google for 28 kinds of local business, from plumbers and painters to physios and accountants, across 13 areas around Geelong. Each search was "[business type] [area]", run on a phone from the middle of that area. It's the same data as our study of 4,400 Geelong-region businesses on Google. This time I looked at the normal results under the map, the top ten for each of 363 searches.
Directories took 31% of those top-ten spots. Facebook and Instagram took another 12%. And 96% of searches had at least one directory in the top ten. For the 156 trade searches it was 154, so nearly all of them.
Here's how often each one appeared in the top ten:
- Yellow Pages: 34% of all searches, 47% of trade searches
- hipages: 28% of all searches, 60% of trade searches
- Localsearch: 28% of all searches, 46% of trade searches
- MapQuest: 20%
- Yelp: 17%
- Whereis: 17%
- Airtasker: 15% of all searches, 29% of trade searches
- HotDoc, Healthshare and Fresha: 9 to 12% of all searches, all of them health, beauty or wellness
Facebook beat all of them. It turned up in 64% of searches and 76% of trade searches.
One that barely showed: True Local had 5 top-ten spots across all 363 searches.
Where you are changes the picture
Directories took far more of the results in the smaller areas than in Geelong itself:
- Mount Duneed: 39% of top-ten spots
- Waurn Ponds: 35%
- Lara, Bannockburn and Belmont: 34%
- Ocean Grove: 25%
- Torquay: 22%
- Geelong: 16%
My read is that it comes down to websites. In the main study, around a third of listings in Lara and Mount Duneed had no website, against 15% in Geelong. With fewer local sites to show, Google fills the gap with directory pages.
The same pattern holds for searches for our own kind of work. When we checked 22 searches for web design, social media and IT support around Geelong on 28 October, Localsearch was in the top ten for 6 of them.
What a directory listing actually does for you
A directory listing does two jobs.
The first is direct. If Yellow Pages or hipages ranks for "electrician Lara" and you're not listed there, the people who click it never see you. In trade searches, those three directories showed up so often that being missing from them means missing a real share of clicks.
The second is indirect. A local citation is any mention of your business name, area and phone number on another site. Google's local ranking help page says prominence is based partly on how many websites link to your business. A listing that links to your website is one of those. The same page also says there's no way to pay Google for a better local ranking, so a directory can't sell you that either.
Is Yellow Pages worth paying for?
I'd separate the free listing from the paid upgrade.
A basic listing with your correct name, phone, service area and website link is worth having on the directories that show up for your trade. In our check Yellow Pages was in the top ten for nearly half of trade searches, so I'd want to be there.
Paying for a featured spot is a different question, and I can't answer it with this data. We counted where directories rank, not how many enquiries a paid listing brings in. What I'd do is ask the rep how many people viewed or called businesses like yours in your area last year, and decide from that. If they can't tell you, that tells you something.
Be careful with offers out of the blue. Scamwatch warns that scammers target small businesses by requesting payment for directory listings, advertising and domain renewals that were never ordered. If an invoice turns up for a listing you don't remember, check it with the company using contact details you find yourself.
Which ones I'd do first
For a trade business around Geelong:
- Your Google Business Profile, before any directory. It's the map, and it's free.
- Facebook, because it showed up more than any directory.
- hipages, Yellow Pages and Localsearch, the three that kept turning up for trade searches.
- Airtasker if you take small jobs.
For a health, beauty or wellness business, add the booking or health directory your clients already use, like HotDoc, Healthshare or Fresha.
Keep the details identical everywhere. Google's guidelines for representing your business ask for your real-world name and an accurate address or service area. Use exactly the same name and phone number on every directory so they all point clearly at one business.
Then point every listing at your website. Directories rank for the search, but your site is where people decide to call. If yours needs work, what to put on your business website covers the pages that matter.
If you do one thing this week, search your trade and suburb on your phone, scroll past the map, and claim your free listing on any directory that shows up in the top ten.