Most owners I talk to ask some version of the same question: what actually gets you into the top three on Google Maps? Is it reviews, a website, or just luck?
I didn't want to answer that from gut feel, so we checked.
What we looked at
On 30 October 2026 we searched Google for 28 kinds of local business across 13 areas: Geelong, Torquay, Bannockburn, Armstrong Creek, Mount Duneed, Waurn Ponds, Belmont, Grovedale, Highton, Lara, Ocean Grove, Leopold and Drysdale.
Each search was "[business type] [area]", run from the middle of that area, the way someone there would search on their phone. We recorded up to 40 Google Maps results and the top 20 normal Google results for each one.
The business types were a mix:
- Service businesses: physios, chiros, osteos, podiatrists, massage therapists, psychologists, dentists, home care and NDIS providers, commercial cleaners, hairdressers, beauty salons, personal trainers, dog groomers, accountants and mortgage brokers.
- Trades: plumbers, electricians, builders, house cleaners, landscapers, painters, roofers, carpenters, concreters, air con installers, pest controllers and locksmiths.
That came to 363 Maps searches and 4,471 different businesses. For each one we noted its reviews, photos, ranking and whether its Google profile links to its own website. A profile that only links to Facebook or Instagram counts as no website here. We haven't named anyone.
Reviews: the first ten matter most
The businesses in the top three had a median of 14 Google reviews. Those ranked 21 to 40 had 6.
Here's how often a business made the top three, by how many reviews it had:
- No reviews: 7%
- 1 to 9 reviews: 12%
- 10 to 49 reviews: 15%
- 100 or more: 17%
The biggest jump is from none to a handful. Going from 50 reviews to 150 helps a little. Going from zero to ten roughly doubles your odds.
That matches what Google says itself. Its local ranking help page says prominence is based on info like how many reviews you have, and that more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking.
One thing that didn't matter: star rating. The median rating was 5.0 both inside and outside the top three, so almost everyone looks the same on stars.
Reviews, website and ranking together
Here's how often each group made the top three:
- No website, under 20 reviews: 8%
- Website, under 20 reviews: 12%
- No website, 20 or more reviews: 15%
- Website, 20 or more reviews: 16%
A website helps most when reviews are thin. With no reviews at all, businesses with a website made the top three 9% of the time, against 5% for those without. Once a business had ten or so reviews, the gap on Maps mostly closed.
So on Maps, reviews do most of the heavy lifting. The website earns its keep in other places, which I'll get to below.
Photos showed up too. Profiles with no photos made the top three 4% of the time. Profiles with even a few photos made it 12% of the time or more.
Smaller areas are much easier to win
The bar for the top three changes a lot depending on where you are. Here's the median review count of the top three businesses in each area:
- Bannockburn: 8.5
- Armstrong Creek and Leopold: 10
- Lara: 11
- Mount Duneed: 13
- Ocean Grove, Waurn Ponds and Drysdale: 14
- Highton and Grovedale: 15 to 16
- Torquay and Belmont: 18
- Geelong: 33.5
In Bannockburn, Lara, Leopold and Armstrong Creek, about half the top-three spots went to businesses with fewer than 10 reviews. In Geelong it was about a quarter.
The newer growth areas had another gap. When someone in Waurn Ponds searched, most of the top three businesses that show an address weren't based in Waurn Ponds at all. In Mount Duneed it was close to half. If you work in those areas, there's room to be the local option.
The smaller areas also had more businesses with no website. Around a third of listings in Leopold, Lara, Drysdale, Mount Duneed and Armstrong Creek had none, against 15% in Geelong.
Directories take a big share of normal Google results
Below the map, the normal Google results look different. About a third of the top ten results (34%) were local businesses' own websites. Directories took almost as many (31%), mostly Yellow Pages, hipages, Localsearch, MapQuest and health booking sites, and Facebook and Instagram took another 12%.
Only 11% of businesses with a website had it show up in the top 20 for their own search. For businesses already in the Maps top three, that rose to 26%.
A correction: an earlier version of this section said 14% and 6%. Google returned many website links in a redirect format our first count missed, so it undercounted business websites. The figures above are the recount, made on 15 November 2026 from the same search data.
That's why I'd treat a website and directory listings as part of the same job. Google says prominence also covers how many websites link to your business. Your website is the thing those directories and local sites link to, and it's where people land once they've found you.
Does any of this cause better rankings?
Not on its own, and I want to be straight about that. These numbers show what travels together. They don't prove one thing causes another. A busy, established business tends to have more reviews, more photos and a website all at once. Google also weighs how close you are to the person searching, which none of this captures.
I also went looking for a solid study comparing enquiries for small businesses with and without a website, and couldn't find one that traces back to real data. There are plenty of stat lists online, but they quote each other, so I've left them out.
What Google does say is that customers are 70% more likely to visit a business with a complete Business Profile. Reviews, photos and a website link are all part of complete.
What I'd do first
If you're not in the top three for your area, I'd start here, in this order:
- Search your business name on Google Maps and make sure the profile is claimed. If you see "Own this business?", it isn't.
- Get your first ten reviews. Ask your last few happy customers. Our guide on getting more Google reviews covers how to do it within the rules.
- Add a few real photos of your work, your team or your premises.
- Link a website, even a simple one-page site. If you're building one, what to put on your business website covers the pages that matter.
If you're in a smaller area like Bannockburn or Lara, the first two steps alone could put you in the running.
One exception on reviews. If you're a registered health practitioner, like a physio, psychologist or dentist, patients can still review you on Google, but Ahpra's advertising guidelines ban using testimonials about clinical care to advertise. Don't share or repost those reviews, and take care replying to them. That may be part of why some health categories in our check had so few reviews.